New York enforceability and choice-of-law opinion letters.
Zlotowitz Law issues New York law opinion letters for commercial real estate financings: borrower's counsel opinions, local counsel opinions, and New York enforceability and choice-of-law opinions for loans secured by property in any state. Chaim C. Zlotowitz, admitted in New York, issues each opinion personally, for a fixed fee agreed before engagement.
When a New York opinion is needed
- The loan agreement, note or guaranty is governed by New York law, and the borrower's regular counsel is not admitted in New York.
- The property is in New York, and the lender requires a local counsel opinion on the mortgage and other New York matters.
- The borrower or a guarantor is a New York entity, and the lender requires an opinion on its existence, authority and due execution of the loan documents.
What a New York opinion typically covers
The scope follows the lender's opinion requirements and is settled with lender's counsel.
- Enforceability
- The loan documents governed by New York law are valid and binding obligations of the borrower and guarantor, enforceable in accordance with their terms, subject to customary assumptions and qualifications.
- Choice of law
- A New York court would give effect to the choice of New York law in the loan documents. Section 5-1401 of the New York General Obligations Law permits the parties to a transaction of $250,000 or more to choose New York law, with limited exceptions, whether or not the transaction has another connection to New York.
- Usury
- The loan does not violate the usury laws of New York.
- Entity matters
- For New York entities: existence and good standing, power and authority, and due authorization, execution and delivery of the loan documents.
- No conflicts or consents
- Signing and performing the loan documents does not violate New York law or require a New York governmental approval.
- Mortgage matters
- For New York property: the mortgage is in proper form for recording and creates a lien on the property.
How it works
Send the documents
Email the loan documents and the lender's opinion requirements. Drafts are fine.
Fixed fee
We agree on a fixed fee before engagement.
Draft opinion
We review the loan documents and the organizational documents, and send a draft opinion to lender's counsel.
Closing
Questions and lender comments are handled promptly, and the signed opinion is delivered for closing.
Selected New York opinion matters
| Financing amount | Opinion type | Year |
|---|---|---|
| $42,200,000 | New York choice-of-law opinion | 2026 |
| $8,400,000 | New York choice-of-law opinion | 2026 |
Amounts reflect the underlying loan transactions. Client names omitted. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Common questions
What is a New York enforceability opinion?
It is a letter from New York counsel, addressed to the lender, stating that the loan documents governed by New York law are valid and binding obligations of the borrower, enforceable in accordance with their terms, subject to customary assumptions and qualifications.
Lenders commonly require it as a condition of closing a commercial real estate loan.
What is a New York choice-of-law opinion?
When loan documents choose New York law but the borrower or the property is in another state, the lender often asks New York counsel to confirm that a New York court would honor that choice.
Section 5-1401 of the New York General Obligations Law permits parties to a transaction of $250,000 or more to choose New York law, with limited exceptions. Section 5-1402 addresses the choice of a New York forum for transactions of $1,000,000 or more.
The property is not in New York. Can you still give the opinion?
Yes. The New York opinion covers the documents governed by New York law, typically the loan agreement, the note and the guaranties.
The mortgage or deed of trust, and other matters of local real property law, are usually covered by counsel in the state where the property is located. Zlotowitz Law gives New York opinions for financings of property nationwide.
Can you be engaged only for the opinion?
Yes. In many engagements the borrower's own counsel handles the loan transaction, and we are engaged only to issue the New York opinion.
Do you use the lender's form of opinion?
Yes. We work with lenders' preferred opinion forms and coordinate any necessary revisions with lender's counsel.
How is the fee set?
We agree on a fixed fee before engagement. The fee depends on the scope of the opinion, the number of borrower and guarantor entities and the documents covered.
What do you need to get started?
Send the loan documents (drafts are fine), the lender's opinion requirements or form of opinion, the organizational chart and organizational documents for each entity covered, and the target closing date.
General information about opinion practice, not legal advice about a particular transaction.
Need a New York opinion letter?
Also: New Jersey opinions · Pennsylvania opinions · All opinion letters